U.S. Officers Roundly Criticize Effort to Train Iraqi Forces

The WaPo reports today that, flaws have been cited in the “effort to train Iraqi forces” and “U.S. officers roundly criticize a program that is growing in importance”:

The U.S. military’s effort to train Iraqi forces has been rife with problems, from officers being sent in with poor preparation to a lack of basic necessities such as interpreters and office materials, according to internal Army documents.

The shortcomings have plagued a program that is central to the U.S. strategy in Iraq and is growing in importance. A Pentagon effort to rethink policies in Iraq is likely to suggest placing less emphasis on combat and more on training and advising, sources said.

In dozens of official interviews compiled by the Army for its oral history archives, officers who had been involved in training and advising Iraqis bluntly criticized almost every aspect of the effort. Some officers thought that team members were often selected poorly. Others fretted that the soldiers who prepared them had never served in Iraq and lacked understanding of the tasks of training and advising. Many said they felt insufficiently supported by the Army while in Iraq, with intermittent shipments of supplies and interpreters who often did not seem to understand English.

The Iraqi officers interviewed by an Army team also had complaints; the top one was that they were being advised by officers far junior to them who had never seen combat.

Some of the American officers even faulted their own lack of understanding of the task. “If I had to do it again, I know I’d do it completely different,” reported Maj. Mike Sullivan, who advised an Iraqi army battalion in 2004. “I went there with the wrong attitude and I thought I understood Iraq and the history because I had seen PowerPoint slides, but I really didn’t.”

MY TAKE – In Vietnam, our government thought we could win by saturation bombing, harrassment and interdiction, free fire zones, and “Vietnamization”. Today, it’s “shock and awe”, green zones, and Power Point presentations……… When are we going to remember the power of plain old DIPLOMACY and STATESMENSHIP ? Oh that’s right, a guy that could actually accomplish that wasn’t elected in 2004…….what was I thinking anyways?!?!!

Bookmark and Share

Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to U.S. Officers Roundly Criticize Effort to Train Iraqi Forces

  1. RH says:

    We can’t train our American troops not to murder civillians, what in the world makes us think we can train the Iraqies. Thats like the Fox news saying they are fair and balanced.

  2. battlebob says:

    I must have missed something.
    They had at least a half a million troops.
    Don’t you think they could have been turned into police?