Girl-on-Girl Cruelty Leads to Teen Death

Mean Girls Mobbing  

Girl-on-Girl cruelty, some say, a rite of passage, has been widely chronicled, and somewhat celebrated, in pop culture, movies, TV Shows, and teenage literature. Nice Lindsay Lohan – plays a 15 year old high-school teen – turns mean to join a clique in the movie Mean Girls.

But after the recent suicide of Phoebe Prince,15, in South Hadley, Massachusetts, officials have adopted a new seriousness to the subject. District Attorney Elizabeth Scheibel aggressively indicted nine teenage girls on criminal charges of statutory rape, violation of civil rights, criminal harassment, and disturbing a school assembly.

“Their conduct far exceeded the limits of normal teenage relationship-related quarrels,” Scheibel said of the nine teens, the oldest of whom is 18 years old, according to the Boston Globe.

Phoebe, a pretty high school freshman who had recently emigrated from Ireland, hanged herself after intense bullying at school, via Facebook, and text messaging. The Mean Girls called her an Irish Slut. It was a tortuous for her said the DA. Her crime: a brief fling with a high school football player. Her parents complained to school officials many times.

Too often, American schools foster a culture of cliques and teasing isolation which torments millions of children who have no place to turn. This culture of mob mentality and peer conformity has led to a record number of suicides, murders, and psychological scars that never heal. Since 1960, suicides among American teenagers have more than doubled.

Today, more than 3,000 teens kill themselves each year. 250,000 attempt suicide.

How many kill other people? In a survey by Bolt Media of more than 4,000 teenagers, 47% answered “Yes” to the question “Could one of your classmates be a killer?” This large number indicates that teens themselves are aware of their peers inability to cope. 

The American Medical Association found that 1 in 10 boys have been kicked in the groin by age 16. Twenty five percent of these kicks resulted in an injury and, most tellingly, a quarter of the injured boys exhibited signs of depression a year after the injury. National statistics show that 30-35% of students are either bullies or victims of a bully.

The big problem is that educators and parents are still on the wrong side and in denial of the cancer that is crippling so many of our youth. Blaming the victim makes life easier for almost everyone.

They largely operate on the premise of “benign neglect” — that students have to work out their social problems by themselves and that teachers should not interfere with this childhood “rite of passage.”

But it is precisely this ethos of secrecy that thrives in the embarassed shadows of teenaged souls that allow this brutality to thrive.

But there is another way. A growing movement from abroad in Sweden and Canada has begun to challenge these premises. A book on mobbing by Dan Olweus shows that this kind of culture of cliques, social torture, and cruelty can be changed by educators. “Bully Beware” programs have been successful in dozens of schools around the world.

Unfortunately, few of these schools are in the U.S. and these notions are not being accepted by traditional American educators.

And the laws are still murky. Prince’s needless death and the 2009 death of 11-year-old Carl Joseph Walker-Hoover, 11, of Springfield, recently led the Massachusetts’s Senate and the House to push through new anti-bullying measures. A few years ago Washington State Senate passed legislation aimed at cracking down on bullying, but not without opposition. Some of the Republicans questioned whether a law could fix the problems of bullies.

One study of pediatric leukemia patients showed that they associated their worst pain not with chemotherapy, surgery, or spinal taps but with “going back to school and being teased.”

We have seen this particular brand of American poison many times before.

The mass teenage murders in Santee, California and Littleton, Colorado and the massacre at Virginia Tech flow directly from widespread neglect of mobbing behavior by educators and teachers.

Consider what might have happened if any of the schools had been attentive to such problems, but no one was trained to be sensitive to such problems and the possible consequences of traditional teen-age cruelty.

The story is the same at all the schools. The disturbed killers clearly gave off signs of alienation and dysfunction for months, if not years. They were being tormented by the “jocks” and others at the school until they felt they had no choice but to react as they did, with fatal consequences.”

The problems of bullying are everywhere, in every school, town, and city in America. If nothing changes, the consequences and mayhem will continue to traumatize the entire nation, again and again.


Bookmark and Share

About Blake Fleetwood

Blake Fleetwood Blake Fleetwood was formerly on the staff of The New York Times and has written for The New York Times Magazine, New York Magazine, The New York Daily News, the Wall Street Journal, USA Today, the Village Voice, Atlantic and the Washington Monthly on a number of issues. He was born in Santiago, Chile and moved to New York City at the age of three. He graduated from Bard College and did graduate work in political science and comparative politics at Columbia University. He has also taught politics at New York University. He can be reached at
Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Girl-on-Girl Cruelty Leads to Teen Death

  1. Blake

    Thanks so much for writing this and sharing it here on The Dem Daily. It’s heartbreaking to know that school officials knew of Phoebe’s tormentors and did nothing.

  2. Scott Nance says:

    I am surprised and disappointed, too, that this happened in South Hadley. I covered the South Hadley schools for a local newspaper there about 15 years ago. South Hadley is home to Mount Holyoke College and is part of the so-called “Happy Valley” of liberal college towns in Western Mass. (Amherst, Northampton and their surrounding towns). It is supposed to be a diverse, accepting place. So what happened here really disturbs me on an additional level.